Ice Cream Wasn’t in the Plan, But It’s Here to Stay

Ice Cream Wasn’t in the Plan, But It’s Here to Stay

If you had told me a year ago that I’d be elbow-deep in churned cream, dreaming up flavors like Matcha Pistachio or Maple Bacon Crunch, I probably would’ve laughed (or cried, depending on the day). Olivia’s Goodie Shop has always been about baked goods—cookies the size of your palm, cinnamon rolls you smell from the sidewalk, birthday cakes made with love.

But ice cream? That was a curveball.

It started small. A customer asked if I ever thought about making ice cream. Another said, “You know what would be good? Something cold to go with this brownie.” And before I knew it, I was researching machines, testing bases, and sneaking in late-night flavor experiments between custom orders.

What happened next? Hershey’s was here!!! Despite the rumors, we split shortly after their arrival; amicably.

 🍦 Our Flavor Philosophy: Small-Batch, Big Personality

What makes our ice cream different? We treat it like we do our baked goods—from scratch, no shortcuts, and packed with character. Every flavor has its own little story or vibe. New flavors rotate seasonally, and yes—we’re taking requests.

How to Get  (Before It’s Gone)

 Since we’re a small-batch operation, I make a limited number of pints each week. Here’s how you can snag one:

Follow us on Facebook & Instagram for flavor drops and updates

  • Order online or by message—I’ll let you know what’s in stock
  • Pickup at the bakery window during posted hours or by appointment

Once they’re gone, they’re gone… until next week.

💭 So… Is This Just a Summer Thing

Nope. Ice cream is staying. It’s now a full part of the Olivia’s Goodie Shop family, and I’m excited to keep experimenting and expanding. Think holiday-inspired flavors, custom sundae kits, ice cream sandwich boxes, and maybe—just maybe—a little freezer merch down the road.

What started as a whim has become a new creative outlet I didn’t know I needed.

And that’s the beauty of a small business—you never know what’s going to stick until you scoop it.

— Monica @ Olivia’s Goodie Shop

📍 119 East Blue Ridge Street, Stuart, VA

📞 (276) 692-8745 | 💻 www.oliviagoodieshop.com

Back to blog